9. Disputes involving older children / wishes and feelings

  • Older Children’s Wishes and Feelings

    Help to ensure an older child’s views are presented appropriately while keeping the case focused on welfare, safeguarding and the child’s best interests.

    Older child expressing their wishes and feelings while parents listen during a family discussion

Technical Matter Guide

Law, procedure and guidance checked 22 September 2026

Older children in family proceedings: how much weight does the court give their wishes?

The Family Court must listen to children without transferring adult decision-making responsibility onto them. As a child approaches adolescence and adulthood, their views may carry substantial — sometimes decisive — practical and welfare weight. But age alone does not create an automatic veto. The court asks what the child thinks, how those views were formed, how maturely they are held and how they fit within the child's welfare as a whole.

No fixed-age rule: There is no rule that a child reaches 12, 13, 14 or another particular age and can automatically decide where they live or whether they spend time with a parent. Section 1(3)(a) Children Act 1989 requires the court to consider the child's ascertainable wishes and feelings in light of their age and understanding. What changes as children mature is usually the weight and practical significance of their voice — not the underlying welfare test.
2

How does the court hear the child's voice?

A child does not usually give evidence in a private-law case simply because the adults disagree about what the child wants.

There are several less adversarial ways of ensuring that their voice reaches the court.

Cafcass assessment

A Family Court Adviser may meet the child and report their wishes, feelings, experiences and welfare needs to the court.

Section 7 report

Where ordered, a section 7 welfare report should include the child's wishes and feelings where the child is of sufficient age and understanding to express them.

Child Impact Report

In Child Focused Court areas, the child's experience and voice are gathered much earlier through the more investigative model.

Children's Guardian

In more complex cases a Rule 16.4 guardian may be appointed after the child is joined as a party.

Meeting the judge

A child may ask to meet the judge. The judge decides whether that is appropriate and the meeting is generally about participation and understanding rather than privately collecting evidence.

Letter or communication to the judge

Cafcass may discuss whether the child wishes to communicate their views through a letter, drawing or another appropriate method.

Child Focused Courts: the child's voice earlier in the process

The developing Child Focused Court model changes the timing of children's participation.

Rather than the court waiting months for an independent account, the model places earlier information-gathering and the child's experience at the centre of the case. Cafcass describes participating areas as providing earlier opportunities for children to explain their wishes and feelings.

A meeting with the judge is not a private fact-finding interview

The Family Justice Council's guidance on judges meeting children explains that the purpose is principally to help the child feel involved and enable them to understand the judge's role.

A judge cannot promise a child that everything said will remain secret from the parties. Important information relevant to the court's decision cannot simply be converted into private evidence that nobody else has an opportunity to address.

Explaining the outcome to the child

Participation should not end once the court has obtained the child's views. The President of the Family Division's current guidance encourages judges to communicate decisions to children in an appropriate way, including through letters explaining what was decided and why.

This is especially important where the court has heard the child's wishes but has reached a different conclusion.

3

Weight, authenticity, influence and safeguarding

The fact that a child's view has been influenced does not automatically mean it is false. Children are influenced by their experiences, relationships, parents, peers, school and wider environment — as adults are.

The court's task is more careful: understand how the view developed and what it tells the court about this child's welfare.

Question Why it matters
How long has the child held the view? A persistent position may carry different significance from a response to a single recent event.
Is the account consistent? Consistency across time and different professionals may help the court understand authenticity, although inconsistency can itself have explanations.
Does the child give their own reasons? Nuanced, child-specific reasoning may be relevant when distinguishing the child's voice from repetition of adult language.
Is the child frightened? Fear may arise from actual harmful experiences and should not automatically be characterised as influence.
Is the child managing an adult's emotions? Loyalty, worry, parentification or a wish to protect a parent may affect how freely the child feels able to speak.
What happens when they express another view? A child may feel safer agreeing with one household than expressing ambivalence or affection for both.
What has the child actually experienced? Their position should be considered alongside the factual history, safeguarding evidence and any judicial findings.

S v D & Anor [2023] EWHC 984 (Fam): influenced does not necessarily mean inauthentic

The case concerned a boy approaching 15 who wished to remain living abroad after years of intense parental litigation.

The judge concluded that the mother had exposed him to her strong hostility towards the father and that this had affected the father-son relationship.

Nevertheless, the judge found the boy's wish to remain abroad to be genuinely his. His views were nuanced, mature and repeatedly expressed. By that stage, forcing his return was likely to cause significant harm.

The case demonstrates why “he has been influenced” is not an adequate substitute for analysing the child's actual voice and welfare.

Read S v D [2023] EWHC 984 (Fam) →

Reluctance, resistance or refusal to see a parent

The Family Justice Council's current guidance cautions against jumping from a child's refusal to see a parent to a diagnostic or blame-based conclusion.

The court should consider potential explanations including:

  • domestic abuse or harmful parenting;
  • a child's own experience of the relationship;
  • harmful parental conflict;
  • adult behaviours affecting the child's relationship with another parent;
  • fear or anxiety;
  • developmental factors;
  • loyalty conflicts;
  • relationship rupture;
  • and combinations of these factors.
4

When does the child become a participant or party?

Most children in ordinary private-law proceedings are the subject of the case but are not themselves parties to it.

Their voice will commonly reach the court through Cafcass rather than through their own solicitor.

Rule 16.4 representation is exceptional, not routine

Under FPR Part 16 and Practice Direction 16A, the court can make a child a party and appoint a children's guardian where the case contains sufficiently significant difficulty or complexity.

PD16A identifies circumstances that may justify doing so, including cases where:

  • the child's standpoint is inconsistent with that of the adult parties;
  • the child's wishes cannot adequately be represented through an ordinary welfare report;
  • there are particularly complex welfare issues;
  • the case is exceptionally difficult or intractable;
  • there are significant international issues;
  • or separate representation is otherwise required to protect the child's interests.

Guardian's welfare position and child's instructions can differ

A children's guardian represents what they independently assess to be in the child's interests. That is not necessarily identical to what the child says they want.

FPR 16.29 provides an important safeguard. Where the child's solicitor considers that the child wishes to give instructions which conflict with those of the guardian and has sufficient understanding to give those instructions, the solicitor must conduct the proceedings in accordance with the child's own instructions.

Mabon v Mabon [2005] EWCA Civ 634: autonomy and articulate teenagers

Mabon remains a foundational authority on older children's participation.

Three teenage boys wished to instruct solicitors independently rather than have their case advanced through their guardian.

The Court of Appeal emphasised the growing recognition of children's autonomy and participation rights. The relevant question was whether the individual child had sufficient understanding to participate in the particular proceedings.

The court warned against an overly paternalistic approach that prevents an articulate young person from participating simply because adults think they know what is best for them.

Read Mabon v Mabon [2005] EWCA Civ 634 →

5

Teenagers, enforceability and what happens around age 16

The older the young person, the more important it becomes to distinguish between what the court is legally empowered to order and what can realistically be achieved.

Re C (Older Children: Relocation) [2015] EWCA Civ 1298

Re C concerned two boys aged 17 and 15.

The Court of Appeal warned of the particular caution required when courts attempt to regulate the lives of older teenagers. It observed that imposing arrangements contrary to an older child's wishes may be inappropriate and even futile.

The point is practical as well as legal: as a child approaches adulthood, the ability of either parents or courts to control everyday personal decisions steadily diminishes.

Read Re C [2015] EWCA Civ 1298 →

The position at 16 is more nuanced than “all orders end”

The Children Act contains specific age restrictions on section 8 orders.

Making new orders after 16 Section 9(7) generally prevents the court making a new section 8 order in respect of a child who has reached 16 unless the circumstances are exceptional, apart from an order varying or discharging an existing order.
Most section 8 provisions Section 91(10) ordinarily causes section 8 provisions to cease when the child reaches 16 unless they lawfully continue beyond that age.
Lives-with provisions Section 91(10A) creates an important exception for Child Arrangements Order provisions regulating with whom, or when, a child is to live.
Ultimate end point Where a section 8 order lawfully remains effective after 16, section 91(11) provides that it ends at 18 if still otherwise in force.

Legal force is not the same as practical enforceability

Even where an order technically remains in force, a court will be acutely conscious of the practical reality of attempting to compel an articulate 16- or 17-year-old to live or spend time in a way they strongly oppose.

That does not mean teenagers have permission to disregard every court order. It means that welfare, autonomy, proportionality and the realistic reach of judicial intervention become increasingly important.

S v D [2023]: ten months can be a long time in a teenager's life

When revisiting the position of the 14-year-old boy in S v D, the High Court recognised that his circumstances and views had developed significantly in less than a year.

By the time of the later hearing, his mature and strongly held wish to remain where he had settled demanded very substantial respect. The court concluded that forcing him to return would itself cause harm.

This is a useful reminder that welfare evidence about a teenager can become stale quickly. Their school life, friendships, identity, maturity and understanding may develop considerably during prolonged proceedings.

6

Key authorities, official guidance and practical preparation

Mabon v Mabon [2005] EWCA Civ 634

Leading authority on the participation and independent representation of articulate older children. Emphasises autonomy, the child's right to participate and an individual assessment of sufficient understanding.

Read the judgment →

Re H-B (Contact) [2015] EWCA Civ 389

A private-law contact case involving older teenage children who were separately represented. Useful both on the particular care required in older-child disputes and on the statutory limitations affecting section 8 orders around age 16.

Read the judgment →

Re C (Older Children: Relocation) [2015] EWCA Civ 1298

Particularly important for the practical limits of court intervention with older teenagers. The Court of Appeal cautioned against making orders that conflict with an older child's strongly held wishes where effective regulation may no longer be realistic.

Read the judgment →

S v D & Anor [2023] EWHC 984 (Fam)

A modern example of a mature teenager whose wishes became a major welfare factor. The court distinguished parental influence from the authenticity of the young person's own views and concluded that coercing a different outcome would cause harm.

Read the judgment →

C (A Child) (Change of Given Name) [2024] EWCA Civ 1582

Useful contemporary authority on the statutory duration of Child Arrangements Order provisions. The Court of Appeal confirmed the specific effect of sections 91(10), 91(10A) and 91(11) in relation to lives-with provisions extending beyond age 16.

Read the judgment →

Questions a litigant in person should be able to answer

  • How old is the child?
  • What exactly is the court being asked to decide?
  • What has the child actually said?
  • Who obtained those wishes and feelings?
  • When were they obtained?
  • Were they expressed privately and in an age-appropriate setting?
  • Has the child's position been consistent over time?
  • What reasons does the child give?
  • Are those reasons specific to the child's own experiences?
  • Does the child feel responsible for either parent's wellbeing?
  • Are there allegations of domestic abuse, fear or harmful parenting?
  • Are relevant allegations admitted, disputed or already the subject of findings?
  • Has anybody suggested that the child's views are influenced? What actual behaviour supports that assertion?
  • Does the child have communication, neurodevelopmental or learning needs affecting how their views should be gathered?
  • Has Cafcass met the child recently enough for the assessment still to be current?
  • Would a section 7 report adequately convey the child's position?
  • Is Rule 16.4 representation being considered, and why?
  • Does the child want to meet or communicate with the judge?
  • If the court makes an order contrary to the child's wishes, how could it realistically operate?
  • What will the child be told about the decision and why it was made?

Primary sources and official guidance

  1. Children Act 1989 — particularly section 1, sections 9 and 10, and section 91.
  2. Practice Direction 12B — Child Arrangements Programme — includes the requirement to consider the child's wishes and feelings and place children at the centre of proceedings.
  3. Family Procedure Rules Part 16 — children as parties, guardians and representation.
  4. Practice Direction 16A — Representation of Children — including Rule 16.4 appointments and circumstances in which separate representation may be appropriate.
  5. Cafcass — Role in Private Law Proceedings — including section 7 reports and children's wishes and feelings.
  6. Cafcass — What happens when a child is made a party under Rule 16.4
  7. Family Justice Council — Guidelines for Judges Meeting Children
  8. Judiciary — Guidance on Writing to Children — published in 2025 and updated in March 2026.
  9. Family Justice Council — Guidance on Reluctance, Resistance, Refusal and Allegations of Alienating Behaviour

Is an older child's voice becoming central to your case?

JSH Law can help you analyse Cafcass material, separate the child's actual words from adult interpretation, organise the chronology, identify safeguarding and participation issues and prepare clear, child-focused court documents.

Start with the latest order, the child's age, the decision currently before the court and the most recent professional record of their wishes and feelings.

Book a Free 15-Minute Consultation
Information notice: This page provides general legal and procedural information for England and Wales. It is not advice on the facts of an individual case. The significance of a child's wishes and feelings depends on their individual age, understanding, experiences, welfare needs, safeguarding circumstances and the particular decision before the court. JSH Law provides non-reserved legal services, litigation support and McKenzie Friend assistance to litigants in person. JSH Law is not an SRA-authorised solicitors' firm and does not provide regulated solicitor representation or conduct litigation on your behalf.

Most Recent Entries