Coercive Control Is a Trajectory, Not an Incident: Dr Christine Marie Cocchiola’s Warning for the Family Court
JSH LAW | COERCIVE CONTROL · CHILDREN · FAMILY JUSTICE | ENGLAND AND WALES
By Jessica Susan Hill · Research and legal position checked 20 November 2026
Coercive control is sometimes described as “hidden abuse”. That can be helpful, but it risks inviting the wrong question: can anyone see evidence of a particular incident? In her important new essay, Coercive Control Is a Trajectory of Abuse, published on 20 November 2026, Dr Christine Marie Cocchiola proposes something more searching. Examine the development of control over time—its origins, its maintenance, what happens when the survivor seeks to leave and how the alleged tactics change when control is threatened.
That framework has immediate relevance for the Family Court in England and Wales. A dispute over handovers, a changed relationship with a child, an angry message or repeated proceedings may be a fragment of a much larger history. Equally, those events may have benign, mixed or unrelated explanations. The task is to investigate the relevant trajectory, test the competing accounts, and assess the individual child’s welfare—not to presume abuse because a pattern is alleged.
1. The trajectory: four questions that change the investigation
First: how was control established?
Dr Cocchiola observes that some survivors remember early affection, closeness, intense attention and shared aspirations. Love, trust or returning to a relationship are not evidence that later abuse could not have occurred. Nor is early intensity, commonly called “love bombing”, proof of manipulation. What matters is what subsequently happened: did the relationship develop into one in which an adult could not meaningfully disagree, decline demands, see others or make independent decisions without consequences?
Second: how was the control maintained?
A course of behaviour may involve isolation, surveillance, finances, humiliation, coercive demands, changing rules, intimidation or the use of children to exert pressure. The alleged impact may be progressive: a person gives up friends, changes work, anticipates another’s anger or spends increasing energy avoiding punishment. What appears outwardly to be agreement may, in some cases, reflect adaptation to threats or unequal power.
The Home Office statutory guidance stresses repeated or continuous behaviour and cumulative impact. It also warns that a victim’s serious distress may not be obvious on first observation. The absence of visible injury does not negate the possibility of non-physical abuse.
Third: what happened at separation?
Separation may end living together without ending the means of control. The alleged tactics may move into child arrangements, electronic communications, school decisions, financial pressure, repeated calls or court proceedings. Legitimate litigation and child welfare concerns must never be treated as abusive automatically. Investigators need to ask whether the pattern, context and effect suggest attempts to dominate, or whether an action has another reasonable explanation.
Fourth: what happened when independence was asserted?
Did control decline, intensify or move to another channel when boundaries were established? How did the person allegedly exercising control respond to being told “no”, to a separation, to a professional’s intervention or to an order? Were threats and pressure replaced with apparently polite but repeated demands? Or did matters settle? The chronology must be allowed to answer these questions; the answer should not be assumed in advance.
The court needs more than an inventory of incidents. It needs a reliable account of their sequence, their context, their consequences, and whether they form a legally relevant pattern.
2. When a survivor’s reaction is mistaken for the whole story
A professional may first encounter a frightened, angry, unusually detailed or guarded parent. They may see an abrupt refusal of a handover, numerous emails about safety, or a parent who struggles to speak calmly. Presentation alone does not establish why the person behaves that way. Anxiety is not proof of coercive control; composure is not proof of safety; irritation is not proof of dishonesty.
Consider this fictional example. A parent refuses a face-to-face handover and sends an angry message. Read by itself, the message may suggest obstruction. Read alongside verified records of previous intimidation at handovers, a safety plan and a request for a neutral meeting place, it may suggest an attempt to establish a boundary. If those earlier events are disputed, the other parent’s explanation must also be considered. The court’s job is to determine what matters on evidence.
The term “high conflict” can be a poor substitute for analysis. Some disputes arise from mutual difficulties and competing needs; others may involve a persistent imbalance of power. Using the same label for both can obscure risk. Conversely, asserting that one person is a victim cannot resolve every factual dispute. A fair assessment distinguishes conduct, source, chronology and impact.
Research into legal abuse in family-court proceedings examines how legal processes may sometimes extend coercive control after separation. The research creates an important question for practitioners, but no automatic inference that a particular application, appeal, complaint, legal argument or disputed expert report is itself abuse.
3. Children are not observers outside the trajectory
Children may see, hear or experience the effects of controlling behaviour without themselves being struck. Under section 3 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021, a qualifying child affected in these ways is recognised as a victim for the Act’s purposes. The Children Act 1989 directs courts to the child’s welfare, including emotional, psychological and other harm.
Control may affect which adults a child feels able to approach, how freely they speak, what they think will happen if they express affection for either parent, and whether they believe they must manage a parent’s emotional reaction. But the child’s behaviour is never a diagnostic shortcut. A child may love a parent who has behaved abusively. A child may refuse contact for legitimate reasons unrelated to abuse. A child may express an authentic adolescent preference. Several causes may coexist.
The Family Justice Council’s December 2024 guidance on a child’s reluctance, resistance or refusal to spend time with a parent and allegations of alienating behaviour is essential. It rejects the idea of a diagnosable “parental alienation syndrome”, emphasises the child’s voice, and makes clear that determining disputed allegations of abuse or alienating behaviour is a judicial task.
That creates two equally important cautions: a child’s rejection is not automatically proof of alienating behaviour by one parent, and it is not automatically proof of coercive behaviour by the other. Both hypotheses require evidence, a proper opportunity to answer, and a child-centred assessment.
- What was the child’s relationship with each parent over time, and what changed?
- What did the child say in their own words, to whom, and in what circumstances?
- Was the child interviewed without pressure, and were leading questions avoided?
- Are there contemporaneous observations from school, health professionals or other reliable sources?
- What explanations have been considered and what remains uncertain?
4. The legal position in England and Wales
The definition of domestic abuse
Sections 1–3 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 encompass coercive or controlling behaviour, economic abuse, and psychological or emotional abuse. Physical violence is not a necessary ingredient of every form of domestic abuse. The section 76 Serious Crime Act 2015 criminal offence is separate, with defined ingredients including repeated or continuous conduct, a serious effect, personal connection and the required knowledge. Its extension to relevant post-separation conduct came into force on 5 April 2023 and does not operate retrospectively.
Family proceedings are not a criminal prosecution. A criminal conviction is not required before the Family Court can determine relevant allegations or protect a child. Equally, family findings are not criminal convictions. The court assesses disputed facts on the civil standard, the balance of probabilities, where findings are necessary.
The child’s welfare remains paramount
Section 1 Children Act 1989 puts welfare first and requires attention to the child’s wishes and feelings, needs, likely effect of change, harm suffered or risked and parental capacity. The qualified, rebuttable presumption of parental involvement in section 1(2A) remains operative on 20 November 2026. It does not require equal parenting time, unsupervised visits or contact that would put the child at risk of harm.
The Courts and Tribunals Bill proposes repealing that presumption, but as of this article’s date it has not become operative law. Safeguarding duties and welfare analysis apply now, irrespective of future legislative reform.
PD12J: how allegations should be managed
Practice Direction 12J applies where domestic abuse is raised in relevant child arrangements proceedings. It calls for the identification of relevant factual and welfare issues and, where necessary, directions for fair and proportionate determination. Paragraph 17 concerns whether a separate fact-finding hearing is necessary. Paragraph 18 requires reasons to be recorded if none is held. Paragraph 19 addresses the selection of key disputed facts and evidence. The court can consider statements, relevant schedules or tables, and proportionate third-party disclosure.
The court may also consider sections 91(14) and 91A Children Act 1989 where future applications risk harm, including in appropriate cases where proceedings themselves form part of domestic abuse. Restricting an individual’s access to court requires a justified basis; it is not the ordinary response to persistent disagreement.
Forward-looking procedural note: amendments to several Family Practice Directions, including PD12J, are announced to commence on 18 December 2026. Check the version in force at the time of the relevant hearing. See the Family Procedure Rules updates.
5. The cases: why context matters, but proof still matters
F v M [2021] EWFC 4
Hayden J’s judgment illustrates how the dynamics and cumulative effects of coercive and controlling conduct can emerge from the wider course of a relationship. Its facts are specific; it is not an invitation to impose a standard narrative of abuse onto every family. Read the judgment.
Re H-N [2021] EWCA Civ 448
The Court of Appeal recognised the danger of analysing alleged coercive or controlling behaviour solely through a narrow set of separate incidents, while stressing careful identification of relevant findings. Pattern recognition must be supported by evidence and must assist the welfare decision. Read Re H-N.
K v K [2022] EWCA Civ 468
The Court of Appeal made clear that allegations do not automatically require a separate finding-of-fact hearing. Necessity, proportionality, relevance to welfare and the available evidence govern case management. Read K v K.
Re D [2026] EWCA Civ 969
This Court of Appeal decision reinforces the distinction between safeguarding risk assessment and judicial determination of disputed facts. A professional’s report may highlight risk and recommend enquiries, but it must not quietly turn contested allegations into established events. Read Re D; see also JSH Law’s explanation.
Re C [2026] EWCA Civ 1216
In Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court), handed down on 29 September 2026, the Court of Appeal explained that the Child Focused Court model aims for more investigative, child-centred proceedings but does not change the substantive law. PD12J, procedural fairness and welfare still govern. The appeal against limited supervised contact failed on its particular facts, but a section 91(14) restriction imposed against the mother was set aside because the requisite justification had not been shown. Read Re C and JSH Law’s case review.
The cases do not prescribe a predetermined winner. They require proper analysis of the relevant history, proportionate case management and evidence-based welfare decisions, including the rights of each party to a fair process.
6. Constructing a trajectory evidence map: a practical method
A litigant in person rarely helps the court by filing every historical message and asking the judge to infer the pattern. A better approach is a short chronology with source references, agreed or disputed status, and the child’s welfare implications. The following fictional example shows the structure rather than supplying a model allegation.
| Date/stage | Alleged conduct | Original source | Effect / child relevance | Evidence status | Issue for decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before separation | Repeated restrictions on visits with relatives | Full dated messages | Contact with family reportedly reduced | Disputed allegation | Was there a coercive restriction or different reason? |
| At separation | Threats allegedly linked to handovers | Complete message export | Neutral handovers requested | Messages authentic; meaning disputed | What was intended, said and understood? |
| After safety boundary | Many calls from new channels | Call records and context | Alleged distress and disruption | Conduct shown; purpose disputed | Was it necessary contact or continued pressure? |
Seven steps for a litigant in person
- Define the live question. Is the court deciding interim safety, fact-finding, the terms of contact, the scope of a report or a disclosure issue? Include only history that helps.
- Preserve primary records. Keep complete messages, chronology, original documents and lawful metadata. Do not misrepresent selected screenshots as whole exchanges.
- Distinguish evidence status. Label allegations, admissions, contemporaneous observations, professional opinions and findings separately.
- Identify a change over time. Show when conduct allegedly began, changed channel, escalated, diminished or ceased, especially after separation or protective boundaries.
- Describe real-world effect. Identify the alleged impact on autonomy, safety, everyday parenting and this child, not abstract traits of another adult.
- Record competing accounts. What reasonable alternative explanations exist? Which material might favour the other party? State what remains unresolved.
- Ask for a focused direction. The court needs the minimum evidence sufficient for a safe and fair welfare decision; avoid an indiscriminate data dump.
JSH Law’s related pieces include Robert Kaiser’s research on behavioural trajectories, Dr Emma Katz on distorted obligations and fairness, and Walking on Eggshells: Coercive Control, Children and the Family Court. These articles offer complementary perspectives, not substitute legal tests.
7. Questions to ask of a Cafcass or social-work assessment
A good assessment identifies its sources, the chronology, the issues not resolved, the child’s actual experience and the limits of its conclusions. If a report seems to assume that one parent’s evident stress equals hostility, or that another parent’s composed manner disproves risk, ask exactly where those inferences came from.
- Which period of the relationship and post-separation history did the assessment cover? Why?
- Did the assessor distinguish alleged isolated incidents from a possible repeated controlling pattern?
- What evidence supported the view taken, and what did the other party say in response?
- Were changes following separation, refusal, an order or a safeguarding intervention considered?
- What does the child actually report? Who asked, when and with what safeguards against leading questions?
- Was the difference between a professional’s risk opinion and a fact judicially determined made explicit?
- What explanations other than coercive control were actively explored?
- How does each identified concern translate into a specific recommendation for this child?
An inaccurate report may be corrected or challenged through proper procedural channels, but error does not itself show malice, collusion or intentional abuse. Professional criticism is strongest when it identifies a particular statement, its source, an omitted document, a failure to test an allegation or a material welfare consequence. It is not strengthened by speculative diagnoses of a professional’s personality.
8. What can a parent actually ask the court to do?
The appropriate request depends upon the stage of proceedings and the evidence. Options may include a direction for a focused statement, a concise evidence table, proportionate police or third-party disclosure, clarification of the scope of a section 7 or Child Impact Report, a reasoned decision about whether fact-finding is necessary, measures to enable fair participation under FPR Part 3A/PD3AA, interim safeguarding, or a review of an arrangement where a material welfare issue has arisen.
This is illustrative wording, not a filing template that overrides an order. An existing child arrangements order remains binding unless varied, stayed or otherwise lawfully dealt with. Urgent safeguarding risks may require immediate protective measures or contact with emergency services. In imminent danger call 999.
9. What a trajectory can—and cannot—prove
- There is no inevitable sequence. Coercive control may begin early or later, change form, reduce or stop. A difficult separation does not by itself forecast violence.
- A chronology cannot create facts. Dates make patterns easier to see, but the sources, context and evidence still require scrutiny.
- Disagreement is not automatically coercion. Parenting differences, awkward communications and lawful court applications have many possible explanations.
- Clinical labels are not shortcuts. Terms such as narcissist, psychopath or trauma-bonded are not a substitute for proving material conduct or properly instructed expert evidence.
- The child’s view needs context. Alleged pressure, genuine wishes, fear and mixed loyalties must be assessed individually, not presumed from silence or refusal.
- Procedural fairness matters. The other party must have a fair opportunity to respond to material allegations, and professionals should identify uncertainty.
- The law is child-specific. A framework or author’s experience does not determine what contact arrangements serve a particular child’s welfare.
Dr Cocchiola’s work invites a deeper inquiry, not a preordained conclusion. That is precisely why its central insight is important for family justice: the relevant evidence may lie not in the most dramatic incident but in the relationship between events, the responses to boundaries and their cumulative effect.
10. Frequently asked questions
Does coercive control have to involve physical violence?
No. The law recognises several non-physical forms of domestic abuse. A specific criminal offence has its own defined ingredients, which should not be conflated with civil family proceedings.
Can post-separation behaviour be relevant to the Family Court?
Yes, where it bears on risk or welfare. Post-separation behaviour may be especially important when comparing how the alleged conduct changed. Criminal liability under the extended section 76 offence depends on the date and statutory elements.
Does an allegation automatically justify a fact-finding hearing?
No. Under PD12J and the appellate guidance, the court considers whether disputed factual findings are necessary and proportionate for the welfare decision.
Does a child rejecting a parent prove that they are controlled or alienated?
No. It is a signal for careful, child-centred assessment, not proof of any single cause. The Family Justice Council’s 2024 guidance should be consulted.
Can Dr Cocchiola’s trajectory model be put before a court?
A parent may explain that they have organised evidence chronologically, but should not portray the model as the statutory test, a clinical diagnosis, a scientific probability of violence or expert evidence without proper foundations.
Sources and further reading
- Dr Christine Marie Cocchiola, Coercive Control Is a Trajectory of Abuse (20 November 2026)
- Home Office statutory guidance on controlling or coercive behaviour
- Domestic Abuse Act 2021, sections 1–3; Serious Crime Act 2015, section 76; Children Act 1989, section 1
- Practice Direction 12J and Family Procedure Rules updates
- F v M [2021] EWFC 4; Re H-N [2021] EWCA Civ 448; K v K [2022] EWCA Civ 468
- Re D [2026] EWCA Civ 969; Re C [2026] EWCA Civ 1216
- Family Justice Council guidance on reluctance, resistance or refusal and alienating behaviour (2024)
- Academic research: Coercive Control in the Courtroom: the Legal Abuse Scale (2022)
- Courts and Tribunals Bill: Parliamentary stages
General educational information, not case-specific legal advice. All illustrative examples are fictional. No confidential or private family proceedings are described. Verify current law and procedure at the date of any hearing.




Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!