Walking on Eggshells: Coercive Control, Children and the Family Court
JSH LAW | COERCIVE CONTROL, CHILDREN AND FAMILY JUSTICE | ENGLAND AND WALES
Legal and procedural sources reviewed: 20 November 2026
A child can appear calm, loyal and compliant while feeling unable to speak freely.
An October 2026 coercive-control conviction, involving a woman who herself worked with domestic abuse survivors, raises difficult questions about what adults and professionals may overlook — and what a Family Court must investigate before drawing conclusions about a child’s wishes.
Coercive control is not always visible as violence. It may be repeated restrictions, changing rules, economic pressure, threats, isolation or monitoring, with the adult or child constantly working to avoid an unpredictable reaction. When a relationship ends, control may continue through communication, child arrangements and litigation.
But a child’s refusal to see a parent is not, by itself, proof of coercive control or of alienating behaviour. The child may have sound reasons to fear or reject that parent, may be experiencing pressure elsewhere, may be expressing ordinary adolescent preferences, or may be affected by several causes. The answer must be investigated, not assumed.
This is a practical, source-linked guide for parents and other adults experiencing controlling behaviour, and for those concerned about a child. It distinguishes law from allegation, explains the leading judgments, sets out protective options and shows how litigants in person can make an evidence-led, child-focused application.
1. The ITV case: the hidden rules of an abusive household
ITV News reported on 29 October 2026 the experience of Tashya, a domestic-abuse charity worker whose former partner Darren Kingscott was convicted of controlling or coercive behaviour. ITV reported a sentence of 20 months’ imprisonment suspended for 18 months, a five-year restraining order and other requirements.
Tashya described almost a decade of restrictions, changing demands and fear of displeasing her partner. Her children were reportedly restricted in where they could spend time, what they could watch and when they could speak to her. Despite her professional work supporting survivors, she described how difficult it had been to recognise the pattern in her own home.
The conviction and sentence are reported criminal outcomes. The detailed household experiences are drawn from ITV’s reporting of Tashya’s account, rather than a published Family Court judgment. Those details should not be treated as findings in another case.
This article does not attempt to identify or discuss any private child or ongoing family proceedings. Its examples are generic and illustrative.
2. What coercive control can look like — for an adult and for a child
Coercion often works cumulatively. An isolated rule can appear ordinary; a repeated pattern that removes independence, creates fear and makes the person’s world smaller may be abusive. The context, power dynamic and impact matter more than the number of screenshots.
Patterns that may warrant assessment
- Monitoring calls, messages, friendships, travel or attendance at school and activities, especially where the rules are one-sided or punitive.
- Changing demands so a family member continually second-guesses what will be acceptable.
- Pressuring a child to report on another parent, keep secrets, express loyalty, or avoid ordinary affection for relatives.
- Restricting contact with trusted family members, siblings, teachers or friends, without a proportionate safeguarding reason.
- Economic abuse, threats about housing or immigration status, interference with work, and using money or important documents as leverage.
- Post-separation interference with communications or arrangements, threats about court, repeated abusive messages, or attempts to use proceedings as control.
None of these observations proves a crime or family-law finding by itself. Parents may impose reasonable boundaries or restrictions for legitimate safeguarding reasons. A professional must ask about purpose, repetition, context, the child’s experience and the existence of credible alternative explanations.
Why children do not necessarily describe the behaviour
A child may love and need a controlling adult, fear upsetting them, feel responsible for keeping the household peaceful, or lack a vocabulary for the behaviour. Their account may differ depending on who is present. A parent who has experienced abuse may also struggle to name it, as the ITV report demonstrates.
Other explanations are equally important. A child might be frightened of a parent they are asked to visit, have experienced harmful parenting, be exhausted by litigation, wish for more independence, or simply prefer current routines. A safeguarding investigation should not pathologise those possibilities.
Control does not automatically stop at separation
The Home Office statutory framework recognises post-separation coercive behaviour. Changes to the section 76 offence effective 5 April 2023 removed the requirement for living together in certain post-separation cases. The criminal offence still has its own statutory elements and must not be equated automatically with a family-law finding of risk.
3. The statutory and procedural framework
The Children Act 1989: welfare and wishes
Under section 1 of the Children Act 1989, the child’s welfare is the paramount consideration in relevant decisions about upbringing. The statutory welfare checklist includes the child’s ascertainable wishes and feelings in light of their age and understanding, needs, likely effect of change, harm or risk of harm, and parents’ capacity to meet needs. A child’s views are important evidence but are neither an automatic veto nor something to dismiss as ‘influenced’ without proof.
The Domestic Abuse Act 2021: children as victims
Sections 1–3 of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 define domestic abuse to include, among other things, controlling or coercive behaviour, emotional and psychological abuse and economic abuse between personally connected adults. Under section 3, a qualifying under-18 who sees, hears or experiences the effects of the abuse is recognised as a victim for the purposes of the Act. That does not mean every child automatically satisfies all elements of a separate criminal charge.
Serious Crime Act 2015, section 76
The offence in section 76 requires repeated or continuous behaviour, the relevant personal connection, a serious effect and the statutory knowledge element. A criminal conviction is not necessary before the Family Court considers domestic abuse as a welfare concern. Conversely, allegations are not judicial findings.
Practice Direction 12J: assess patterns and risk
PD12J governs domestic abuse in child-arrangements cases. It requires early identification of abuse issues, consideration of what findings are necessary, adequate safeguarding, and decisions informed by the impact on the adult victim and child. In particular, paragraphs 17–19 concern proportionate fact-finding, paragraph 21 section 7 reports, paragraphs 25–27 interim arrangements where abuse issues remain unresolved, and paragraphs 35–38 decisions once domestic abuse is established.
A court should not collapse multiple allegations into a vague label such as ‘parental conflict’, nor assume every disagreement is coercive control. The legal question is what behaviour is material to child welfare, whether it is established, and which protective or contact arrangements are proportionate.
Child reluctance and the Family Justice Council
The Family Justice Council’s December 2024 guidance addresses reluctance, resistance or refusal. It rejects a diagnosable ‘parental alienation syndrome’, stresses that the court must make factual findings, and requires examination of abuse and justified rejection before reaching conclusions about harmful adult influence. Cafcass’s guidance follows the same broad child-centred discipline.
4. Nine significant judgments: the legal lessons
These are nine particularly relevant reported decisions, not every case in which coercive control, reluctance or contact was considered. Court of Appeal rulings must be distinguished from first-instance judgments, which may illustrate legal reasoning without establishing a universal outcome. Each case title links to a judgment or official judgment page.
| Case | What it means | Practical application |
|---|---|---|
| F v M [2021] EWFC 4 | Hayden J examined coercive control as a pattern which can degrade autonomy and safety. The significance lies in the cumulative behaviour, not a search for one dramatic incident. | Give dated examples together with their cumulative effects. Avoid isolating a handful of messages from their broader context. |
| Re H-N and Others (Children) [2021] EWCA Civ 448 | Court of Appeal guidance: examine patterns of coercive control holistically and identify which issues require findings for future welfare decisions. | Connect alleged conduct to a specific safeguarding and child-arrangements decision. |
| Re K (K v K) [2022] EWCA Civ 468 | A fact-finding hearing is not automatic because abuse is alleged. It should be necessary and proportionate for the welfare decision; not all parental conflict is domestic abuse. | Explain why each disputed incident or pattern actually needs to be resolved. |
| Re S (Parental Alienation: Cult) [2020] EWCA Civ 568 | Demonstrates judicial examination of established harmful interference with family relationships in an unusual factual setting; not a presumption that refusal always results from influence. | Focus on particular proven conduct and the child’s welfare, not an alienation label. |
| Re C (‘Parental Alienation’; Instruction of Expert) [2023] EWHC 345 (Fam) | Separates the court’s fact-finding responsibility from the expert’s proper role; diagnostic labels cannot establish adult misconduct. | Do not invite a psychologist to determine which party is truthful. |
| Re CTD (A Child) (Rehearing) [2020] EWCA Civ 1316 | Relevant where an earlier factual finding is challenged. The circumstances for revisiting prior findings are legally controlled, not simply a fresh disagreement. | Identify genuinely material new evidence or procedural defects; seek case-specific advice. |
| Re Y (Experts and Alienating Behaviour: The Modern Approach) [2026] EWFC 38 | Emphasises a sequential, evidence-based inquiry into a child’s rejection, including justified response to harm, before any conclusion that an adult caused unjustified resistance. Earlier findings were set aside. | Ask whether the assessment has considered abuse and other explanations before proposing alienating behaviour. |
| D (Change of Circumstances: Domestic Abuse Allegations) [2026] EWCA Civ 969 | Court of Appeal found error where a welfare assessment and order materially relied upon disputed abuse allegations being treated as established. The need for findings can require reconsideration. | Check if a Cafcass recommendation assumes an unproved allegation and request a proper, proportionate judicial determination. |
| Re C (Child Arrangements Orders; Domestic Abuse; Child Focused Court) [2026] EWCA Civ 1216 | PD12J remains applicable under the Child Focused Court approach. The court must assess the risk of contact and the possible harm from stopping a relationship; it need not follow Cafcass, but must give reasons. | Ask for an explicit welfare assessment of competing risks and protective possibilities, not automatic contact or no contact. |
Three distinctions which matter in practice
Re H-N and Re K are complementary, not contradictory: conduct must be assessed holistically where relevant, but a separate fact-finding hearing must still be necessary and proportionate. A court should not be asked to determine every historical argument merely because there has been conflict.
Re Y and the Family Justice Council guidance reject starting with a conclusion that a child has been ‘alienated’. The sequence begins with what the child has actually experienced and whether refusal might be justified by harm from the parent they resist. Only then can other explanations, including harmful adult influence, be fairly explored.
Re D and Re C (2026) demonstrate different aspects of fair adjudication. Re D is a warning about relying on disputed allegations as if established; Re C requires a reasoned assessment of both safety and the potential impact of restricting a child’s relationships. Neither judgment supplies a predetermined answer to a particular family’s circumstances.
5. Evidence: showing the pattern rather than merely alleging it
A clear chronology is often more useful than a large, unordered bundle of screenshots. It should identify what happened, when, where it is recorded, what is disputed, how the child was affected and what the court is being asked to decide. Preserve original messages, timestamps and surrounding context. Do not alter records or invite a child to gather evidence.
The evidence you may lawfully have
- Dated messages, call records, photographs or other material already in your possession; retain originals and full context.
- The last sealed child-arrangements order, relevant handover records and an accurately dated history of contact or communication.
- School, health, local-authority or support-service records obtained lawfully, with appropriate safeguards and disclosure directions where necessary.
- A contemporaneous note of a child’s words freely volunteered, noting the date, exact words as best remembered and who was present. Do not repeatedly interrogate or coach the child.
- The adult’s evidence of repeated rules, monitoring, financial interference, intimidation and their cumulative effect; independent corroboration where available.
- Professional reports distinguished by what the author personally observed, what they were told, what they inferred and what a court has actually found.
Illustrative evidence matrix
| Dated event | Evidence status | Welfare question | Proportionate next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scheduled telephone call did not occur | Call log shows failure; reason unknown | Was the child unavailable, unwilling, restricted or affected by a technical issue? | Seek clarification through appropriate adult channels |
| Child spontaneously expresses worry about upsetting an adult | Contemporaneous note, context recorded; untested | Does this indicate fear, ordinary frustration or something else? | Consider independent safeguarding assessment |
| School reports a change in presentation | Professional observation; cause not established | What happened, when, and what other explanations exist? | Consider focused lawful disclosure |
These examples are invented purely to demonstrate record-keeping. They do not describe a real family or establish that a missed call or a child’s statement proves abuse.
6. What to do when you or your child may be unsafe
Immediate safety
If someone is in immediate danger, call 999. For a non-immediate child safeguarding concern, contact the children’s social care service where the child lives using GOV.UK’s reporting guidance; a school safeguarding lead may be another appropriate first contact. For non-emergency police reports, use 101. Do not treat urgent risk as merely an issue for the next routine court hearing.
For the adult experiencing control
- Use a safe device and method of communication if monitoring or threats are suspected. Consider advice from a specialist domestic abuse service before confronting the controlling person.
- Record the repeated behaviour and effects using a safe storage method. Avoid trying to provoke a new incident for evidence.
- Consider whether an application for a non-molestation or occupation order is appropriate. The official starting form is FL401, but eligibility, protection and evidence requirements are fact-specific.
- Discuss whether legal aid is available where there is domestic abuse or child protection evidence. You can find an authorised legal-aid adviser.
- In existing proceedings, raise safe participation, any need for special measures and appropriate directions rather than being forced into unsafe informal discussions.
For someone worried about a child
- Listen without leading questions or suggesting how the child should answer professionals. Never ask them to act as an investigator.
- Record spontaneous words accurately and identify any contemporaneous evidence without putting the child at risk.
- Use emergency services or safeguarding channels according to urgency. If family proceedings are active, notify the court and any children’s representative using the correct process.
- Review existing orders. If there is a genuine emergency affecting ordered arrangements, seek urgent professional advice and court directions rather than assuming a safeguarding complaint suspends an order.
- Request an independent, child-centred assessment which examines the child’s safety, the reasons for any change in important relationships, and safe arrangements for maintaining family or sibling ties where appropriate.
The National Domestic Abuse Helpline provides confidential specialist support. Use a safe device where communications may be monitored.
7. What a litigant in person can ask the Family Court to do
Where relevant, a new application for child arrangements commonly uses Form C100; Form C1A provides supplementary allegations of harm or domestic abuse. Depending on the existing proceedings, a C2 or an application for directions at a hearing may be more appropriate. Check the exact procedure, applicable court order, MIAM requirements or exemption, directions and urgency.
A proportionate list of possible directions
- Identify disputed domestic-abuse issues and determine whether a focused fact-finding hearing is necessary to make a safe welfare decision under PD12J.
- Specify what a section 7 report or Child Impact Report should address: the child’s lived experience, fear or pressure, justified rejection, existing relationships, and realistic safe options.
- Seek only relevant, proportionate disclosure from police, school, health or social-care agencies under a proper court direction.
- Ask for participation measures under FPR Part 3A and PD3AA where vulnerability or domestic abuse impairs effective participation.
- Seek clear interim arrangements and a child-focused timetable, whether that involves suitable supervision, indirect contact, other safeguards or temporarily restricting unsafe contact.
- Where the statutory criteria are engaged, ask the court to consider section 91(14) restrictions on further applications, recognising they are protective rather than a routine response to litigation difficulty.
The court needs an issue, not a label
Present each alleged behaviour in neutral terms, identify its evidence, explain its possible effect on this particular child, and say which decision is needed. Do not ask the court to ‘declare parental alienation’ or to treat allegations as already proved. Explicitly consider the possibility that contact resistance is a justified response to abuse by the resisted parent.
8. When a Cafcass or social-work report does not explain the child’s situation
A professional report may be influential, but the judge decides disputed facts and welfare. A report can accurately record a child’s wish without adequately exploring why the child holds it. It can also fail if it treats an unproved allegation of abuse as established. A structured response should identify precise omissions and inaccuracies, not attack the professional personally.
- Were the child’s words recorded accurately and with the interview context, including who was present and whether they felt safe to speak?
- Were the child’s reasons for resisting a parent tested against the possibility of harmful parenting or a justified response to abuse?
- Were alternative explanations, including pressure, loyalty conflict, changing relationships, adolescence and attachment, considered fairly?
- Were reported matters clearly separated from direct observations, professional inferences, admissions and court findings?
- Was the past relationship with the parent or siblings explored without assuming it guarantees a future arrangement?
- Did recommendations address both risks from contact and the possible harm of stopping a safe relationship, as appropriate?
- Were safeguarding concerns considered under PD12J, with the need for fact-finding reassessed as the case developed?
In Re D [2026] EWCA Civ 969, the Court of Appeal emphasised that assessment and decision-making cannot rest materially upon disputed allegations treated as established. This is a point about legal and evidential discipline, not a reason to dismiss every professional risk assessment or demand fact-finding in every case.
JSH Law’s line-by-line guide to challenging an inaccurate social-worker report sets out a practical way to prepare a concise evidence-based response.
9. Example wording and the JSH Law six-question check
Illustrative wording for a directions request
I ask the court to consider whether the present welfare assessment sufficiently examines the circumstances in which the child’s wishes and feelings have developed. I do not suggest that the child’s position must have been caused by coercive control or influence from either parent. My specific concern is [identify the dated behaviour/change and its evidence status], supported by [identify documents or witnesses]. I recognise that other explanations may include [identify them fairly]. I seek [a focused assessment, disclosure or case-management direction] so the court can determine the child’s welfare with proper regard to safety, lived experience and important family relationships, consistent with the Children Act 1989 and Practice Direction 12J.
Not a prescribed court form or a substitute for case-specific legal advice. Use only allegations genuinely supported by your available material.
Six questions before asking for a direction
- What happened? Give the observable event rather than a theory of motive.
- What proves or records it? Identify source, date, context and any gap.
- What is the evidential status? Alleged, admitted, independently observed, professionally assessed or judicially found?
- What are the alternative explanations? Include reasonable explanations unfavourable to your own case.
- Why does this matter for the child’s welfare? Identify safety, emotional needs, communication or relationships.
- What exactly should the court do? Seek one or more proportionate directions or a clear welfare decision.
10. Questions parents frequently ask
If there was no physical assault, is it still abuse?
Potentially, yes. Emotional, psychological, economic and controlling or coercive behaviour are recognised by domestic-abuse legislation. The criminal offence has additional statutory elements; do not equate a concern with proof of a crime.
Can the court ignore my child’s wish not to see a parent?
The court must consider ascertainable wishes and feelings in light of age and understanding, but it must also consider safety and the full welfare checklist. A child’s views should not be ignored, overridden mechanically or treated as incapable of having been influenced by circumstances.
Does a sudden change in contact prove the child is being controlled?
No. A change may warrant questions about fear, pressure, harmful behaviour by a parent, relationships, life changes or practical difficulties. It proves none of them without proper evidence.
Do I have an automatic right to a fact-finding hearing?
No. PD12J, Re H-N and Re K require the judge to consider whether findings are necessary and proportionate to decide welfare and risk. You can explain which disputed matters must be decided and why.
Can the court order contact where abuse has been established?
Depending on the findings and child’s welfare, the court may consider protective arrangements if safe, or limit or refuse contact where necessary. Re C [2026] emphasises proper reasoning about competing welfare risks, not contact at any cost.
Can I rely on an expert who says my child has ‘parental alienation syndrome’?
The Family Justice Council’s guidance rejects that as a diagnosable syndrome. Courts decide the underlying facts; expert evidence may assist on appropriately defined clinical questions but does not determine adult credibility or factual wrongdoing.
Can I report a safeguarding issue while family proceedings are ongoing?
Yes. Where risk is urgent, use the appropriate safeguarding or emergency channel. Also comply with relevant court directions, confidentiality restrictions and reporting obligations; a safeguarding referral does not automatically change an order.
Has the presumption of parental involvement already been repealed?
No, not as at 20 November 2026. The Courts and Tribunals Bill proposes repeal of the section 1(2A) presumption, but a proposal is not commenced law. The existing presumption does not compel equal care or trump safety and paramount welfare.
Where can I find support today?
In immediate danger, call 999. For child protection concerns use local authority safeguarding guidance. The National Domestic Abuse Helpline can help with safe support, and GOV.UK’s legal-aid directory can help locate regulated legal advisers.
11. Useful linked resources and official authorities
Related JSH Law guidance
- Why Children May Side With the Parent They Fear
- Re C (2026): domestic abuse obligations in Child Focused Courts
- Re D (2026): disputed allegations, Cafcass and fact-finding
- Fact-finding hearings in family proceedings
- Family Court disclosure and records
- Proposed repeal of the parental-involvement presumption
Official law, procedure and support
- Original ITV report of the Kingscott conviction
- Children Act 1989, section 1
- Domestic Abuse Act 2021, sections 1–3
- Serious Crime Act 2015, section 76
- Family Procedure Rules, PD12J
- Practice Direction 3AA, vulnerable parties and witnesses
- Family Justice Council guidance, December 2024
- Cafcass guidance on understanding contact reluctance
- Home Office controlling or coercive behaviour guidance
- Courts and Tribunals Bill, current status
This guide gives general legal information for England and Wales as at 20 November 2026, not advice about an individual case. Outcomes depend on facts, admissible evidence, the procedural stage, existing orders and judicial discretion. JSH Law Ltd is not an SRA-authorised solicitors’ firm. Its services comprise non-reserved litigation support, document-preparation assistance and McKenzie Friend support; it does not undertake reserved conduct of litigation or exercise rights of audience as of right.




© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.


Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!