My Ex Secretly Recorded Our Child: How to Challenge Covert Recordings in Family Court
JSH LAW | FAMILY COURT EVIDENCE | ENGLAND & WALES
Legal review: 17 November 2026
Your ex-partner has secretly recorded your child, produced edited audio clips or says they have recordings that prove you are wrong. What can you do? The correct response is not simply to say ‘the recording was secret, so it cannot be used’. The Family Court must consider relevance, authenticity, context, fairness, proportionality and, above all, the child’s welfare.
The Family Justice Council’s May 2025 guidance on covert recordings provides the framework. It also includes Appendix 4, a guide for people representing themselves. This article concentrates on the parent responding to such evidence and on the safeguarding questions raised when a child has been recorded. For an overview of making or relying on recordings, read JSH Law’s existing covert-recordings guide.
The short answer
Secret recordings are not automatically admissible or inadmissible. Under Family Procedure Rules (FPR) 2010, rule 22.1, the court controls evidence, including by excluding otherwise admissible material. The recording’s content may be relevant, but so may the circumstances in which it was made and any emotional impact on a child.
A covert recording can reveal abuse or serious professional misconduct. Equally, secretly recording a child or surveilling another parent may itself be intrusive, coercive or harmful. These are different situations and require a fact-specific assessment.
1. What counts as a covert recording?
The FJC defines a covert recording as audio or video recorded without the express knowledge and permission of the person recorded. Three situations are particularly relevant in children cases: a parent records a child; a parent records another family member; or a parent records a professional, such as a social worker or Cafcass officer. Recording a private conversation, hiding a device in a child’s clothing or covertly filming contact may all raise questions for the court.
2. Does a recording have to be admitted or excluded?
No. Different issues should be kept separate: lawfulness (was it legally permissible to make or use the recording?), admissibility (should the court receive it?) and weight (how much does it prove?). A genuine recording can still be incomplete, distorted by context or of little relevance. Evidence obtained improperly is not automatically excluded, but the way it was obtained may matter.
A procedural caution: Re B (A Child) [2017] EWCA Civ 1579 questioned the proposition that every covert recording needs prior court permission as a universal rule. The FJC’s 2025 guidance nevertheless emphasises early notification, focused case management and, where appropriate, an on-notice Form C2 application in existing proceedings. The appropriate procedure depends on the kind of recording, the hearsay rules and the orders already made. Do not assume that an unexplained recording can be played at a hearing without directions.
3. Why covertly recording children raises particular welfare concerns
Young people consulted by the FJC described the experience of secret recording as intrusive and capable of breaking trust. A child may be drawn into adult conflict or questioned in ways that distort their words. Discovering later that a trusted adult concealed a device can undermine their security and relationships.
In M v F (Covert Recording of Children) [2016] EWFC 29, a father and his partner secretly recorded a child, including by hiding devices in her clothes. The recordings produced no useful evidence on the disputed issues but damaged relationships and raised concerns about the adults’ understanding of her emotional needs. The father was ordered to bear £1,500 in transcription costs and £9,240 towards the mother’s related costs.
In Re C (A Child) [2015] EWCA Civ 1096, persistent recording and photographing featured in the court’s consideration of emotionally abusive conduct. The significance of these cases is not that recording automatically proves abuse: it is that the act of surveillance can itself be evidence relevant to parenting and welfare. When determining questions relating to a child’s upbringing, the court’s paramount consideration is the child’s welfare under section 1 of the Children Act 1989.
4. Six practical steps if the other parent relies on a secret recording
Step 1: Establish exactly what exists
Make a short schedule for each recording: date, approximate time, duration, location, who was recorded, who made it, whether the child knew, whether any device was concealed and what the other parent says it proves. Distinguish verified facts from your suspicions. Avoid presenting conclusions about intent as if they were established.
Step 2: Ask for the complete, unedited material
A short clip or typed transcript may omit what happened immediately beforehand. Ask the court, where appropriate, to direct disclosure of the full original audio or video file and relevant information about its provenance. The court may also direct an accurate transcript, information about other recordings and access arrangements that protect privacy. Do not edit or ‘improve’ an original file; keep any working copy separate.
Step 3: Identify the issue the recording is meant to prove
Was it offered to prove a threat, an alleged admission or an aspect of contact? A child’s apparent distress in a short recording does not by itself establish its cause. Consider surrounding circumstances, prompting, leading questions, interruptions and whether the other parent is relying on an interpretation rather than the actual words.
Step 4: Explain the welfare impact precisely
If the child was covertly monitored, focus on actual conduct and any demonstrated or reasonably foreseeable harm: breach of trust, intrusion into private conversations, pressure to align with an adult or exposure to litigation. The FJC recommends considering whether the child should be told about recordings and whether separate representation may be needed in a suitable case. Do not repeatedly interview or coach the child.
Step 5: Seek focused court directions
Depending on the circumstances, the court may be asked to address identification of files, complete disclosure, transcripts, disputed passages, authenticity, relevance, secure access, timing of an admissibility decision and whether a separate hearing is proportionate. An expert examination may be justified if authenticity is genuinely disputed and the recording matters to the outcome; expert instructions must follow applicable permission requirements, including Part 25 where engaged.
Step 6: Preserve evidence and avoid further conflict
Keep correspondence and a clear record of what was supplied. Do not share sensitive recordings beyond people entitled to receive them. Do not ask your child to repeat conversations or take sides. Where there is a real safeguarding risk, address it through appropriate professional or court processes.
5. What can a Form C2 application seek?
The FJC discusses an on-notice Form C2 application for parties seeking to rely on covert recordings in existing children proceedings. It recommends setting out the nature, date, method and context of the recording, why it was made covertly and the issue said to make it relevant. A responding party may likewise need directions to enable a fair consideration of the material, but should check the latest sealed order and procedural position first.
Possible directions include a schedule identifying every recording; production of full, unedited files; a transcript with disputed sections marked; explanations of editing or provenance; arrangements for secure access; and a timetable for determining relevance, admissibility and the child’s privacy. See JSH Law’s 2026 Form C2 guide and the official June 2026 C2 form.
Illustrative position-statement wording
“I respectfully ask the Court to give directions concerning the covert recordings the other party proposes to rely upon. In particular, I request identification and disclosure of the full unedited files, clarification of their relevance to the issues in dispute and appropriate directions regarding authenticity, transcripts and the child’s privacy. I ask the Court to consider the circumstances of the recordings and any welfare implications before deciding how they should be used.”
This is an example only, not a prescribed form. Adapt it to the real evidence and the applicable case-management requirements. A position statement is not a substitute for a witness statement, a substantive application or permission to file new evidence.
6. What if Cafcass or a social worker has been given a recording?
The FJC distinguishes a parent openly recording their own Cafcass interview from a professional being sent covert recordings of other people. The guidance records Cafcass’s expectation that Family Court Advisers should not watch or listen to covert recordings offered by a parent during proceedings until the court has determined whether the material can be admitted. It recommends a similarly cautious approach for other professionals.
Cafcass also recognises that, subject to court directions, a parent may record their own interview, with that fact noted in the report. That does not make the recording automatically admissible. The proper route for a disputed recording is through transparent case management, rather than inviting an assessor privately to endorse selected clips.
7. What if the recording was made because of domestic abuse?
It would be wrong to equate a targeted attempt by a victim-survivor to preserve evidence of threats or coercive control with persistent surveillance intended to intimidate. Some covert recordings have revealed professional misconduct or wrongdoing: the FJC discusses Medway Council v A & Ors [2015] EWFC B66, where a mother’s recording exposed inappropriate and racially abusive conduct by a foster carer.
By contrast, HKS v HSM [2021] EWHC 3423 (Fam) involved extensive covert audio surveillance in the family home and findings of coercive and controlling behaviour. Context, power, purpose, pattern and impact matter. Where domestic abuse is alleged in child-arrangements proceedings, Practice Direction 12J is relevant. Never provoke a dangerous confrontation to secure a recording.
8. Can recordings lead to costs, privacy or data protection consequences?
Yes, on the facts. The FJC warns that the domestic or household-use exemption from data protection law is not a blanket defence when personal data is recorded and used in broader contexts. Harassment, privacy and other legal claims may arise. Long transcripts, forensic disputes and additional hearings can substantially increase expense. The M v F costs order illustrates a possible consequence, not a rule that costs follow every covert recording.
9. Could the recording be edited or AI-generated?
Original files matter more than ever. Voice cloning, automatic transcription and audio enhancement can create uncertainty about authenticity. Ask for full recordings and a clear record of any edits or processing where this is genuinely in issue. An inaccurate transcript does not replace the underlying audio. Do not allege fabrication or ‘deepfakes’ without an evidential basis. See our AI and digital evidence guide.
10. Can recordings be posted publicly? Can a parent secretly record a hearing?
Do not assume recordings from children proceedings can be published online or circulated to third parties. Privacy, confidentiality, reporting restrictions, data protection and other law may apply. The FJC states that unauthorised recording of court proceedings, including remote hearings, is prohibited and can amount to contempt of court. Obtain official recordings or transcripts through the proper HMCTS process.
Frequently asked questions
Can I object even if the recording is genuine?
Yes. Authenticity is only one question: the judge must also consider relevance, context, case-management fairness and welfare.
Does a secret recording automatically prove abuse?
No. Its content and the circumstances of its creation require a careful, fact-specific assessment. Covert surveillance may itself be relevant conduct, but conclusions must be grounded in evidence.
Can I demand all of the other parent’s recordings?
You can seek proportionate disclosure directions. The court decides what must be produced and may limit production to what is relevant and necessary.
Should my child be asked about being recorded?
Not by repeated parental questioning. Whether and how the child is informed or involved requires a welfare-led decision; in appropriate cases the court may consider a Children’s Guardian.
Our conclusion: evidence should serve the child, not the reverse
A thoughtful challenge to covert recording is an organised account of what exists, what is missing, what the evidence actually shows and what procedural directions will protect the child while allowing the court to decide the issues fairly. The child must not be made to serve as an evidence-gathering instrument in adult litigation.
JSH Law provides independent non-reserved family-court support for litigants in person in England and Wales, including evidence schedules, chronologies, position statements and practical support with applications and hearing preparation. Contact JSH Law to discuss practical support.
Authorities and further reading
- Family Justice Council, Covert Recordings in Family Law Proceedings Concerning Children (May 2025), sections 3–6 and Appendix 1.
- FJC Appendix 4: Litigants’ Guide to Covert Recording.
- FPR Part 22; Part 23 (hearsay); Form C2.
- M v F [2016] EWFC 29; Re B [2017] EWCA Civ 1579; Re C [2015] EWCA Civ 1096; HKS v HSM [2021] EWHC 3423 (Fam).
Important: This article is general legal information for England and Wales as at 17 November 2026, not case-specific legal advice. JSH Law Ltd provides non-reserved family-court assistance and is not an SRA-authorised solicitors’ practice. Seek regulated legal representation where required, especially for specialist evidence, injunctions or urgent protective applications.


© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.
© 2026 JSH Law Ltd


Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!