When Protection Stops at the Border: Domestic Abuse and Hague Child Return Orders
JSH LAW | INTERNATIONAL FAMILY JUSTICE | ENGLAND & WALES
Research and legal sources checked: 16 November 2026
A court may order a child to return across an international border. But will the protections promised to that child cross the border too?
New Dutch research about domestic violence in Hague Convention return proceedings raises a fundamental safeguarding question: what happens when a parent says they fled abuse, yet the return case is determined quickly, with limited opportunity to test allegations? The answer depends on the child’s circumstances, the legal test and the practical protection available after return—not merely on the promise of a future hearing.
JSH Law examines Nadia Rusinova’s 2026 research, the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention, the distinction between European and British law, and decisions delivered by British courts in 2026. This guide also explains how litigants in person can organise the evidence that matters.
1. The Dutch research: important questions, carefully qualified
International family-law specialist Nadia Rusinova is researching the treatment of domestic violence allegations in Dutch proceedings under the 1980 Hague Convention. Her project runs from January to November 2026, is funded by the MoGa Foundation and involves practitioners from the International Child Abduction Centre (IKO) in the Netherlands. The stated methodology involves analysing Dutch case law and interviewing a limited number of practitioners, with attention to the evidence of violence, judicial risk assessment, protective measures and cross-border cooperation.
A November 2026 LinkedIn post by Giovanni E. Marotta, sharing Rusinova’s announcement, describes a study of 59 Dutch return proceedings between 2015 and 2026. It highlights three themes: the role of independent corroboration; the practical impact of separating children from a primary carer; and how protective measures function across borders, including under the EU’s Brussels II ter framework.
Source limitation: The screenshots shared with JSH Law support that description of the announcement, and Rusinova’s official project page independently confirms the project’s purpose and approach. The complete research report, coding and underlying 59-case analysis were not available for direct examination in this review. We therefore attribute the sample figure and themes to the announcement; we do not present them as independently verified statistical findings or imply that the research proves a particular rate of judicial error.
Rusinova’s free Practical Handbook on EU Family Law, Part 2 provides wider comparative context. The central value for parents in England and Wales is not a claim that Dutch law binds English judges. It is a reminder that a protective measure must work when and where it is needed.
2. The 1980 Hague Convention: what is the actual test?
The Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985 gives the relevant provisions of the Hague Convention force of law in the United Kingdom. The Convention applies to children under 16 and is concerned with wrongful removal or retention in breach of rights of custody in the state of the child’s habitual residence. Questions about habitual residence, custody rights, actual exercise, timing, consent and acquiescence may all matter.
Article 12 establishes the normal obligation of prompt return. Article 13 provides limited exceptions. Under Article 13(1)(b), the person opposing return must establish a grave risk that return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or place the child in an intolerable situation. The burden is on the party resisting return; the standard is the balance of probabilities. This is a high-threshold, forward-looking and child-specific inquiry.
A Hague hearing is ordinarily summary. It is not a conventional trial to resolve every historical allegation of abuse. Courts may, in the appropriate circumstances, assess allegations at their highest and then ask whether they would establish the requisite risk and whether effective measures would address it. The court need not treat every unsupported assertion as true, and the application of the test depends on the available evidence.
Can abuse against the mother or father harm the child?
Yes. In Re E (Children) (Abduction: Custody Appeal) [2011] UKSC 27, the Supreme Court recognised that exposure to physical or psychological abuse of a parent can be relevant to grave risk to a child. The Domestic Abuse Act 2021, section 3, separately recognises related children who see, hear or experience the effects of domestic abuse as victims for the purposes of that Act. Section 3 is not itself a new Hague defence, but reflects contemporary safeguarding understanding.
There is an important distinction between a child’s welfare and the Convention’s return test. Return to the country of habitual residence is not necessarily an order for the child to live with the other parent; equally, the Hague court is not conducting an ordinary final Children Act 1989 welfare assessment. The issue is whether a return order can lawfully and safely be made under the applicable Convention framework.
3. Brussels II ter: an important lesson, but not a UK shortcut
The research announcement highlights Article 27(5) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1111, called Brussels II ter or Brussels IIb. It supplements the Hague Convention for relevant child-return cases within the European Union. Its provisions must not be conflated.
Article 27(3) addresses a case in which the court is considering refusal solely on Article 13(1)(b) grounds. If sufficiently evidenced adequate arrangements secure the protection of the child after return, the court must not refuse return on that basis. Article 27(5) allows a court ordering return to take appropriate provisional, including protective, measures under Article 15, provided doing so does not unduly delay the proceedings. Neither subsection means that a piece of paper automatically protects a child without a workable implementation mechanism.
Brexit qualification: Brussels II ter does not directly govern new child-return proceedings before the English High Court in 2026. EU family-law rules generally stopped applying to new UK proceedings after the transition period ended on 31 December 2020. The 1980 Convention remains applicable; the 1996 Hague Child Protection Convention and domestic measures may be relevant. Older transitional proceedings require careful specialist analysis. See GOV.UK guidance on UK/EU parental responsibility after Brexit.
A litigant in England and Wales should therefore not plead Article 27(5) as a freestanding provision binding the English court. The comparison is useful because it directs attention to the same substantive problem: how, where and by whom is a child’s protection to be delivered after return?
4. Three British judgments that show the difference practical safeguards make
Re A & B [2026] EWHC 1763 (Fam): return refused
In Re A & B, Mr Justice Poole considered a father’s application to return two children to Cyprus. The mother alleged coercive control and serious abuse of her and the children. The father denied the allegations, which were not determined at a conventional fact-finding trial. The court examined the risks if the children returned with or without their mother, including the possible impact of separation from their principal carer.
The proposed measures were insufficient on the case-specific risk assessment. Serious concerns included the availability and enforceability of effective local orders, dependence on the alleged abuser for accommodation funding, the potential psychological impact of renewed coercive control, the uncertainty over the children’s care arrangements and the consequences of separation. The court held that Article 13(1)(b) was established and refused return. This was not a ruling that the Cypriot state generally cannot protect children, nor a conclusive determination that the father committed every alleged act.
Re AL [2026] EWHC 2705 (Fam): return ordered
In Re AL, a five-year-old child’s return to Spain was sought in the face of allegations of domestic abuse, mental-health concerns and the child’s ongoing medical needs. The court examined separate accommodation, financial support, undertakings and the availability of treatment and concluded that the Article 13(1)(b) exception was not made out on those facts. Return was ordered. Our existing JSH Law analysis of Re AL examines the safeguards and expert evidence in detail.
It is important not to misread these decisions as inconsistent. The courts assessed different families, risks, practical arrangements and evidence. Neither judgment establishes an automatic presumption that domestic abuse allegations require return or prevent it.
R v O [2026] EWHC 2421 (Fam): the decisive risk was war
In R v O, Mr Justice MacDonald examined alleged domestic abuse and danger from the war in Ukraine. Taking the abuse allegations at their highest, the court considered that the relevant domestic-abuse risk could be addressed by mechanisms available under Ukrainian law. However, the grave risk from missile and drone attacks in the relevant area could not be adequately mitigated by the proposed plan. The father’s return application was dismissed on that war-related ground.
The judgment also records an important distinction concerning undertakings given in England: they do not necessarily have direct legal force or automatic enforceability overseas. Whether local courts can recognise an order, and how quickly protection can be obtained, must be established rather than presumed.
In the Petition of DM [2026] UKSC 32: listening to children does not remove judicial responsibility
In In the Petition of DM [2026] UKSC 32, a Scottish appeal, the Supreme Court held that the child’s views may be considered when evaluating Article 13(b). Their authenticity, the child’s maturity and their relationship to the risk affect the weight of those views. The fact that a child wishes to return cannot necessarily neutralise an independently established grave risk of extreme psychological harm. The Supreme Court upheld the refusal of return on the particular facts.
5. Will a promised protection actually work after return?
The Hague Conference’s Guide to Good Practice on Article 13(1)(b) (2020) identifies housing, financial assistance, legal services, shelters, healthcare, police and criminal-justice protection as possible safeguards. Paragraphs 43–46 distinguish measures that exist from those that are effective and accessible. A measure may be insufficient despite its formal availability, particularly where there is a history of breached protective orders.
| Proposed measure | Questions the evidence should answer |
|---|---|
| Separate accommodation | Where is it, who chooses it, who funds it, for how long, and can the protected address remain confidential? |
| Undertaking not to contact | Is it voluntary or enforceable? Can a breach be acted upon immediately in the receiving state? |
| Foreign court or police order | Who applies, how soon can it take effect, what conduct is covered, and who enforces it? |
| Finances and access to legal help | Does the parent have independent access to funds, representation, interpretation and emergency proceedings? |
| Medical and therapeutic continuity | Is a provider actually identified and accessible, with a plan for medication, records and existing treatment? |
| Travel, arrival and contingency | Who meets the child, avoids unsafe handover and responds if an arrangement breaks down? |
Legal enforceability is not the same as practical accessibility. A legally valid order may still be unusable without safe transport, independent funds, language assistance or a realistic police response. Equally, it would be wrong to assume a foreign jurisdiction cannot protect a child without reliable evidence about its legal and practical arrangements. That is why specific, verifiable foreign-law information can be so important.
6. Evidence and procedure: what a litigant in person can do
International child-return cases run to an expedited timetable. In England and Wales the High Court deals with these matters under Practice Direction 12F. A respondent must comply with directions, identify any Convention defence promptly and seek specialist advice as early as possible. The Court’s focus is not simply what happened during the relationship, but whether the particular child’s return would expose them to the risk defined in Article 13(1)(b).
- Set out the international chronology. Record habitual residence, rights of custody, dates of departure and disputed retention, prior orders and urgent steps already taken. Do not assume that crossing a border for protective reasons automatically places a move outside the Convention.
- Preserve original sources. Keep unedited messages, medical records, police incident references, foreign orders, documentary evidence of controlling behaviour, accommodation records and contemporaneous safeguarding disclosures. Retain context, dates and provenance.
- Identify the status of each item. An allegation, a record of disclosure, a clinical assessment, a police decision, an admission and a judicial finding are different things. A report not leading to prosecution is not proof that abuse never occurred.
- Explain the link to the child. The court needs to understand the likely impact of abuse of the carer, coercive control, separation from a primary carer, mental-health vulnerability and any direct harm to the child, without assuming contested allegations have already been proved.
- Evaluate the actual return scenario. Who will care for the child upon arrival? Can the returning parent lawfully live and work there? Who pays for accommodation? Will there be safe communication, healthcare and legal protection? What happens before the foreign court can act?
- Use a narrowly tailored issues schedule. Set out the claimed risk, supporting document, evidential limitation, proposed protection and unresolved question. Bring specific gaps to the specialist lawyer’s attention before the hearing.
Do not ask a child to gather evidence, secretly record people unlawfully, make repeated disclosures for an adult’s litigation purposes or disclose private family court material contrary to restrictions. Do not upload sensitive children’s records to an unsuitable public AI service. Follow the court’s confidentiality and service requirements.
If there is an immediate threat of violence or unlawful removal, contact emergency services and obtain urgent legal and safeguarding advice. Where a child is already abroad, the International Child Abduction and Contact Unit and a specialist practitioner may be relevant, depending on the direction of the proposed application.
7. The child is not merely cargo in a jurisdictional dispute
The decision in DM reinforces that children may have their own meaningful perspectives on return, safety, family relationships and the circumstances awaiting them. Whether and how the child should be heard is a judicial decision taking account of age, maturity and welfare. It is not a licence for one parent to coach the child’s answers or for the court to give a child responsibility for deciding the litigation.
Children may be affected by coercive control even where they were not the direct target. They may fear being separated from a protective carer or have legitimate questions about medical care, schooling and stability. Their views do not determine the Convention test, but a properly obtained account can be relevant to the risk analysis. Their wish to return should not be used to disregard a grave risk that the evidence otherwise establishes.
8. JSH Law’s six-question check
A practical preparation framework, not a legal test prescribed by statute.
- Which country was the child’s habitual residence, what custody rights existed and what is alleged to have been wrongful?
- Which Convention exception is actually relied upon, and what evidence supports it?
- What grave physical or psychological harm, or intolerable situation, is anticipated for this child on return?
- How do the asserted abuse, control, separation or other circumstances translate into a child-specific risk?
- Which protective measures exist in the receiving country, and are they funded, accessible, effective and enforceable?
- What happens in transit, upon arrival, pending the first court hearing and if a promise is broken?
Organised answers help a specialist identify the missing evidence and prevent a safeguarding issue from disappearing into a large bundle of material that does not address the legal test.
9. Frequently asked questions
If I fled domestic abuse, was taking my child abroad automatically lawful?
Not necessarily. Convention wrongfulness depends on habitual residence, custody rights and breach of those rights, not solely on a protective motive. That motive can be relevant to the risk inquiry. Obtain specialist advice before any move where possible.
Does a Hague return order mean my child must live with the other parent?
Not necessarily. It is generally a return to the country of habitual residence so that its competent court can address longer-term arrangements.
Must every abuse allegation be proved in a full fact-finding hearing?
No. Hague hearings are summary proceedings. Depending on the evidence and circumstances, a court may assess allegations at their highest for the purpose of evaluating Article 13(1)(b) and the effectiveness of protection. The party opposing return nonetheless bears the burden of establishing the exception.
Can a promise made to the English court protect us abroad?
Possibly, but the legal effect, availability and enforcement of the promise or any local order must be carefully assessed. Undertakings are not automatically enforceable in every foreign jurisdiction.
Can I use Article 27(5) of Brussels II ter in an English case in 2026?
Generally no, not as a directly applicable EU provision in new English return proceedings. The 1980 Convention and applicable English law and procedure govern. Transitional and international complications need individual specialist advice.
10. Sources and further reading
- Nadia Rusinova — Domestic Violence in Dutch Return Proceedings (2026 research project and methodology; full 59-case source report not independently inspected).
- Nadia Rusinova — Practical Handbook on EU Family Law, Part 2.
- Child Abduction and Custody Act 1985, including Schedule 1 (1980 Convention).
- HCCH Guide to Good Practice, Part VI: Article 13(1)(b) (2020), paragraphs 43–46 and related domestic-violence guidance.
- EU Regulation 2019/1111 (Brussels II ter), Article 27(3) and (5).
- GOV.UK — UK/EU parental responsibility after Brexit.
- Practice Direction 12F — International Child Abduction.
- Re A & B [2026] EWHC 1763 (Fam); Re AL [2026] EWHC 2705 (Fam); R v O [2026] EWHC 2421 (Fam); In the Petition of DM [2026] UKSC 32.
General information for England and Wales, not individual legal advice. Outcomes depend on the facts, evidence, foreign law and court procedure. JSH Law Ltd is not an SRA-authorised solicitors’ firm and provides non-reserved litigation support, document-preparation assistance and McKenzie Friend support. It does not undertake reserved conduct of litigation or exercise rights of audience as of right. Preserve the anonymity requirements attached to published family judgments.



© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.
© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!