When the Family Court Breaches Human Rights: Judicial Immunity, Compensation and the 2026 Review
JSH LAW | FAMILY JUSTICE & ACCOUNTABILITY
England and Wales | Legal sources checked 20 November 2026
What happens when the justice system itself violates somebody’s rights?
A new legal exception for judicial acts came into force on 17 November 2026. A separate government review now asks whether broader reform is needed. This article explains both developments, what parents and litigants in person can—and cannot—do, and how to contribute evidence by 8 January 2027.
Family Court proceedings can affect the most important relationships in a person’s life. Parents may fear that evidence was not properly considered, allegations were accepted without an opportunity to respond, or an avoidable procedural failing has had serious consequences for a child. But disagreement with a judgment is not proof of a human-rights violation—and a human-rights violation does not automatically entitle anyone to compensation.
There is nevertheless a serious constitutional question: how can judicial independence be protected without leaving people who have suffered proven, grave violations of their rights without an effective remedy? That is the issue behind the Ministry of Justice’s new call for evidence.
1. What changed on 16–17 November 2026?
17 November: the law was amended
The Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2026 (SI 2026/1205) was made on 16 November and came into force on 17 November. It inserts a further exception into section 9(3) permitting damages to be considered for a judicial act incompatible with Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, because the act was done in such a procedurally defective way that it breached Article 8’s requirements of procedural fairness.
Article 2(2) expressly applies the amendment to judicial acts occurring before and after the Order came into force. That is an important feature of the actual legislation, but it does not abolish ordinary limitation rules, automatically revive concluded proceedings, remove the requirements of section 8 or establish a breach in any individual case. The order can be read here on legislation.gov.uk.
16 November: a separate public call for evidence
On 16 November 2026 the Ministry of Justice opened a public call for evidence on whether section 9(3) remains fit for purpose. Anyone may respond, including people with direct experience of court proceedings, by 8 January 2027. It is an information-gathering review, not a consultation on a published legislative proposal. The government expects to inform Parliament’s Joint Committee on Human Rights of its intended next steps in spring 2027.
The review examines the justification for the existing damages restriction, its effect on judicial independence, instances where compensation might properly be available but is excluded, and the possible consequences of broader exceptions or repeal. It does not review the Human Rights Act as a whole.
2. What section 9 of the Human Rights Act actually says
Courts and tribunals are public authorities under the Human Rights Act. Under section 6, they must act compatibly with applicable Convention rights, subject to statutory qualifications. Nevertheless, judicial decisions have special routes of challenge. Section 9(1) generally restricts proceedings in respect of judicial acts under section 7(1)(a) to a right of appeal, an application for judicial review or another forum prescribed by rules. Section 9(2) preserves legal rules that prevent a court being subject to judicial review.
Section 9(3) limits damages for judicial acts done in good faith. As amended in November 2026 there are three limited exceptions:
| Convention basis | Scope of exception |
|---|---|
| Article 5(5) | Compensation to the extent required where there is a breach of the Convention guarantee relating to unlawful arrest or detention. |
| Article 6 | A fair-trial violation in specified detention circumstances, where without the incompatibility a person would not have been detained or detained as long. |
| Article 8 (new) | A judicial act incompatible with Article 8 because it was sufficiently procedurally defective to breach the Article’s requirements of fairness. |
This is not a general entitlement to sue an individual judge. Under section 9(4), permissible damages are awarded against the Crown with the statutory joinder requirement. Section 8 still requires the court to consider whether damages are necessary to afford just satisfaction; an award is not automatic merely because an act is found incompatible with a protected right.
Section 7 ordinarily provides a one-year time limit for Human Rights Act proceedings from the act complained of, subject to the statutory equitable extension and any stricter deadline imposed by the chosen procedural route. Family appeals may be due much sooner. Whether an earlier judicial act can be litigated today requires an individual assessment of procedural route, limitation, any concluded litigation and applicable law.
3. Why Hammerton and SW changed the law
Hammerton v United Kingdom (2016)
Hammerton v United Kingdom (application 6287/10, 17 March 2016) arose from contempt proceedings connected with a family case. The applicant was imprisoned after proceedings that breached his Article 6 fair-trial rights because of the absence of necessary legal representation. The European Court of Human Rights also identified an Article 13 problem: domestic redress was inadequate in light of the extra deprivation of liberty. The 2020 Remedial Order added a narrowly drawn Article 6/detention exception. The case is not authority that everyone without a lawyer in family proceedings has a damages claim.
SW v United Kingdom (2021)
SW v United Kingdom (application 87/18, 22 June 2021) concerned a professional witness—a social worker—in family proceedings, not a parent challenging a child-arrangements judgment. The Family Court judge made and directed the dissemination of serious professional criticisms without giving the witness a fair chance to address the allegations. The process and resulting interference with private life breached Article 8. The compensation restriction in section 9(3), as then framed, produced an Article 13 violation because an effective remedy was unavailable.
That case explains the new Article 8 procedural-fairness exception. It does not establish that every adverse report, refusal of contact or disputed judicial finding is automatically covered. Read the judgment and the Joint Committee’s further analysis.
4. Why this is especially significant for families
In private and public family proceedings, judicial decisions may determine where a child lives, whether parent–child relationships continue, how a domestic-abuse allegation is examined and whether an affected person can meaningfully participate. Such decisions can engage Article 8 respect for private and family life, as well as fair-process safeguards. Serious errors may have consequences long after a hearing ends.
Illustrative concerns requiring careful investigation could include a person having no genuine opportunity to answer material allegations, major adverse conclusions drawn from evidence not properly put to them, an important procedural barrier to participation, or a harmful failure to afford an appropriate opportunity to be heard. These are examples for analysis, not proof of a violation. The complete directions, hearing record, evidence and judicial reasoning must be considered. There may be lawful explanations for decisions that initially appear unfair.
Where domestic abuse, coercive control or safeguarding concerns arise, the family court’s duties cannot be reduced to a box-ticking exercise; procedural fairness must be assessed alongside protection of the child and any vulnerable participant. But an allegation, a professional assessment, an admission and a court finding remain different evidential categories. See Practice Direction 12J when it applies.
A child’s interests are independent of those of either parent. A parent explaining the impact of a procedural issue should identify evidence of its effects on the child without recruiting the child to gather adult litigation evidence. Related JSH Law reading: The Family Court Crisis and Family Justice at a Crossroads.
5. Appeal, complaint, damages or policy submission?
The right step depends on the outcome you actually need. These four routes are not interchangeable.
| Your objective | Route to investigate | Important limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Challenge a judgment or order | Family appeal (permission where required) or another lawful application | A complaint or government submission does not suspend an order |
| Complain about personal judicial conduct | Judicial Conduct Investigations Office within its remit | It cannot reverse a decision or decide a legal appeal |
| Explore a human-rights remedy | Specialist advice on sections 6–9, the new exception and proper forum | Liability, procedure, limitation and just satisfaction are not automatic |
| Influence future law | MoJ evidence submission by 8 January 2027 | It cannot remedy your individual court case |
Protect appeal deadlines now: GOV.UK family appeal guidance describes a common default of 21 days if no deadline is specified, but some appeals, including case-management decisions, have a seven-day limit. Directions and the applicable rules control the actual period. Do not assume time starts when the sealed order arrives. Consult FPR Part 30 and Practice Direction 30A. See our family appeal guidance.
Conduct complaints concern personal judicial behaviour, not disagreement with a judicial decision or case management: see the official judicial complaints guidance. Where a child faces immediate safeguarding risk, seek urgent advice on protective steps in the current proceedings; do not substitute a long-term policy submission for action on safety.
6. Building an evidence-led account without breaching confidentiality
Whether you are preparing a legal consultation or a public-policy submission, avoid relying on a statement that ‘the court was corrupt’ or ‘the judge ignored everything’. Identify exactly what happened and what source proves it. A useful private working record has six parts:
- The judicial act: decision date, court, judge’s level, order and relevant direction or transcript.
- The procedural problem: the notice, opportunity to respond, evidence, hearing arrangement or procedural safeguard said to be missing.
- What is established: distinguish an allegation, witness account, professional opinion, admission, document and court finding.
- The consequences: specific evidence of impact on the affected adult or child; avoid unsupported causal claims.
- Redress tried: appeal, reconsideration, a later hearing or other procedure; note the result and any dates.
- The unresolved issue: why, despite available correction or challenge, you consider redress to have been ineffective or unavailable.
Use a simple matrix: date | event | primary record | issue | proven or alleged consequence | action taken | outstanding question. Retain original digital files and document provenance. AI-generated summaries may omit qualifications or invent citations; verify every assertion against its source.
7. How to respond to the MoJ by 8 January 2027
The government expressly welcomes contributions from anyone interested in section 9(3). You need not be a legal academic or have succeeded in an appeal to raise a carefully evidenced concern about how remedies operate. But the review is not investigating a personal Family Court complaint.
Submission deadline: 8 January 2027
Email: section9.3HRA.review@justice.gov.uk
Post: Domestic Human Rights Policy Team, Post Point 9.17, Ministry of Justice, 102 Petty France, London SW1H 9AJ.
Read the official call for evidence and terms of reference before submitting.
A structured evidence submission could contain:
- Your interest: for example, anonymised experience as a litigant in person or a professional supporting court users.
- Specific provision: explain that your evidence concerns the operation of section 9(3), not a request to overturn an order.
- Facts and evidence: short, lawfully shareable examples, identifying what is established and what remains contested.
- The redress gap: which appeal, correction or complaint processes were available, what they could remedy, and what harm remained.
- Policy recommendation: whether you favour wider principled exceptions, repeal or retaining section 9(3), with safeguards and reasons.
- Limits: what you cannot establish and why your example may or may not be representative.
For example: “My concern is not that every unsuccessful litigant should receive damages. It is whether a person who proves a serious Convention-rights violation, for which existing remedies are insufficient, should be prevented by section 9(3) from even having the question of proportionate state compensation considered.” This is a proposed policy argument, not a statement that current law grants such a general entitlement.
8. Judicial independence versus effective remedies is a false choice
There are serious arguments for judicial immunity. Judges must decide difficult and unpopular disputes without intimidation, private personal liability or the prospect of routine retaliatory claims. Family proceedings can involve deeply entrenched conflict. An uncontrolled damages regime could impose costs, delay and strategic litigation that ultimately damages justice for children.
But there is also a compelling human-rights problem where a grave violation has been established and no effective remedy is available. Hammerton and SW demonstrated that danger. Parliament’s Joint Committee on Human Rights recommended principled exceptions or the repeal of section 9(3), rather than a sequence of narrow case-specific amendments. The government retained a narrow immediate approach while opening this review.
The relevant questions include whether damages should be considered against the state rather than individuals; whether a threshold should turn on gravity, rights violation and inadequacy of other remedies rather than a closed list of fact patterns; how abusive or repetitive claims could be filtered; and whether access to legal assistance and evidence is realistic for people without representation.
For family justice, reform must also examine irreparable or long-lasting consequences for relationships, while respecting child welfare, case finality and the limits of retrospective litigation. The best submissions will address the argument on both sides rather than suggest that every incorrect decision must generate compensation.
JSH Law’s position: judicial independence deserves robust protection, but it is not synonymous with the absence of accountability. The question is whether the law provides a proportionate, enforceable, effective remedy when a serious violation is proved and existing remedies are inadequate.
9. Frequently asked questions
Can I claim damages because I lost my child-arrangements case?
No automatic right arises. The 2026 exception addresses serious Article 8 procedural unfairness in a judicial act; it does not turn dissatisfaction with an outcome into compensation. The merits, procedural route, time limits and relief require specialist analysis.
Does the change cover older cases?
The Order expressly applies to judicial acts before commencement as well as afterwards. It does not itself revive an expired appeal, set aside a final order or remove relevant time bars. Historic claims need timely case-specific advice.
Can a judicial conduct complaint overturn a judgment?
No. The judicial conduct process is about conduct within its remit. A disputed judicial decision is ordinarily addressed through appeal or another available court procedure, not by a conduct complaint.
Does Article 13 let me make a standalone domestic claim?
Article 13’s effective-remedy principle is central to the Strasbourg cases. But Article 13 is not a separately incorporated Convention right under section 1 of the Human Rights Act. The correct domestic claim must be founded on the actual statutory rights and applicable procedure.
Will the MoJ review suspend my case?
No. It has no automatic effect on a hearing, safeguarding order, appeal period or current proceedings. The review does not decide your personal case.
Can I send my Family Court bundle to the Ministry?
Not without considering the applicable reporting and confidentiality restrictions, data protection and any protective orders. An anonymised summary may be more suitable. Do not assume a policy review creates permission to disseminate private children’s material.
10. Primary sources and further reading
- MoJ public call for evidence: section 9(3) (16 November 2026, deadline 8 January 2027).
- Government terms of reference (scope, timeline and method).
- Human Rights Act 1998 (Remedial) Order 2026, article 2 (effective 17 November, including earlier acts).
- Human Rights Act 1998, section 9; section 7 and section 8.
- Joint Committee on Human Rights: judicial immunity report and subsequent report.
- GOV.UK: family appeals and judicial conduct complaints.
Related JSH Law guidance: Why Family Court Appeals Fail, The Family Court Crisis, and Family Justice at a Crossroads.
JSH Law: evidence-led support when the process feels overwhelming
JSH Law can assist with case chronologies, evidence registers, reviewing the structure of arguments, organising court orders and reports, witness-statement support, appeal paperwork preparation and hearing preparation within its defined non-reserved scope. We can help identify issues requiring specialist regulated legal advice, but cannot conduct reserved litigation on your behalf or promise outcomes.
Have your latest sealed order, decision and deadline dates, a short factual chronology and the particular procedural concern ready. Share confidential case papers only through an agreed lawful secure route.


jsh law ltd
© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.





Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!