Tag Archive for: proportionality

Posts

JSH Law Resources and Guidance for Litigants in Person – practical family court information explained in plain English.© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.

“Welfare Is Not Enough”: Re E [2026] EWCA Civ 1167 and Special Guardianship Orders in Care Proceedings

/
In Re E [2026] EWCA Civ 1167, the Court of Appeal held that a Special Guardianship Order placing a child permanently outside the birth family could not be approached as a simple welfare choice. JSH Law explains why threshold, factual findings, necessity and proportionality matter.

Portfolio Items

Parent reviewing and making notes on Cafcass recommendations for family court proceedings© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.

13. Understanding Cafcass recommendations

A Cafcass recommendation can strongly influence child-arrangements proceedings, but it does not decide the case. This technical guide explains how to trace a recommendation back to its evidence and welfare analysis, distinguish allegations from findings and prepare a focused response if you disagree.
Two people reviewing and annotating documents at a desk with a laptop and organised files

31. Organising evidence and exhibits

Evidence is not persuasive simply because there is a great deal of it. This technical Matter explains how to preserve source records, build a traceable evidence register, prepare exhibits under PD22A and distinguish evidence from what belongs in a PD27A hearing bundle.
Card, envelope and mobile phone representing indirect contact with a child through letters, cards and calls© 2026 JSH Law Ltd. All rights reserved.

5. Indirect contact disputes (letters, cards, calls)

Indirect contact can preserve a child's relationship when direct time is restricted or unavailable. This guide explains letters, calls, cards, safeguarding, court orders and how indirect contact may be reviewed or progressed.
Person working at a desk with a laptop displaying a document workflow, surrounded by folders and paperwork

33. Reviewing and organising large volumes of documents

A large case archive becomes useful only when every document has a reliable identity, is placed against an issue and can be found again. The legal task is to preserve originals while organising working material for the distinct decisions the court must make.
Woman reviewing a laptop displaying a document workflow and checklist at a desk

34. Identifying relevance and proportionality

The question is not whether a document feels important to the dispute. It is whether it is capable of affecting a decision the court is authorised to make, and whether the proposed evidential step is necessary and proportionate.